Thread:Azin62/@comment-28388850-20170813170003/@comment-36213611-20180808130200

Ahahaha so now you want to talk about genetics of levantine people? Well, they are just probably the most genetically diverse and mixed group of people in this world. First, to start with, there is no study on the area that supports your claim that palestinians are arabs from arabia, that is, simply because they are not. I studied this area a lot, I have specialty when the subject is: middle eastern people, ancient civilizations, iranian, turkic and arab peoples, islamic history and how it has influenced all these people.

So, be aware that you are not discussing with a simple moron with a biased opinion based on some superficial crap read on the internet, you are discussing with someone with extreme knowledge in the area. And in fact your continuous reply with extreme lack of content and facts actually makes me think that you are just here for pure arrogance and not for knowledge, you seems to be just the average boi who cannot accept to be defeated in a debate.

Well whatever, lets go to the content, so you cannot accuse me of being also an arrogant. Its already proven in all genetic studies done in the area, in which I studied, that the current people of palestine are for sure descendants of very old semitic peoples of the region, that region mostly includes the nowadays palestine, lebanon and jordan, that is from where they the canaanites a semitic people are native from, they later divided the land among themselves and then with the jews following their invasion of these lands, so here we can see that they the palestinians existed as land and as nation since that times, so pretty much a country following modern concepts. However genetically palestinians are not pure, of course, just like everyone on the region, you can find also in these same palestinians, genes of: greek, iranian, latin, ancient egyptian, assyrian and mesopotamian origin, and of course from arabs that came from the peninsula.

So as you can see the palestinians were always there, they are natives of those lands and always managed to be there independent of who ruled the region, ok understood? Being an arab today does not mean necessarily that you are a desert camel trader who came from the peninsula, the currently concept of being arab is being part of a whole cultural nation of the region, and this does not erase at any time what some of them were in the past.

About the yidish jews, actually, they are more than 50% of the jewish population in israel, and its important to notice that, zionism was actually developed by those same jews, who spoke a germanic language and used at least to live like germans, they had no cultural relation with the middle east anymore, but still they came... Just to name some: theodor herzl, david ben guiron, shimon peres, ariel sharon, menachen begin, chaim weizmann and many more, i did not even mention half of the main zionist authors and there a lot of other politicians also, but guess what, they are all of ashkenazi yidish origin, that is because zionism was created by “germanic” jews. The fathers of zionism in current israel occupied palestine were all yidish jews and some even treated bad and with racism the middle eastern jews. So you see, before making these so called “arguments” you need to make a clear research and the most important, study.

Well, what left of celtic identity nowadays is a very small thing of what it was in the past. We can say that the smallest group survived, ones who identify as celts nowadays are restricted to ireland and non english parts of britain. But the original celts lived in entire of britain, most part of france, plus belgium, netherlands and even in the iberian peninsula. And yes i am mentioning this example, because it has connection with the palestine issue here, and that is because people does not care for whatever happened to them in this case, no one cares that they are currently germanic or latins, but everybody talks some crap when it is about palestine.

Then for the final thoughts on this little debate we had here. Yes i am iranian and muslim with pride, i defend what is correct, do not think that you can have more knowledge in the area than someone who actually studied, its not like just because you read something on the internet and had contact with political propaganda. Being ignorant is not a set feature of people, you can choose to continue one or stop being one.

I am done here, have a good day.