Thread:Azin62/@comment-28388850-20170813170003/@comment-31674709-20180808173201

If Palestinians had different cultural identities in the region, is the Jewish identity a valid one?

So the celtic identity argument is irrelevant, i see.

I'm not snowflake, i'm just pointing on how childish you're behaving by insulting me.

Let me teach you on the Canaanites... Those were aboriginal mostly to Lebanon and North Israel. Now, Jews settled mostly in territory that compromises both Israel and Palestinian Territory as proven by archeology. Yes, their genes may have retained, but it's irrelevant because Canaanites never called themselves palestinians nor were they arab nor jewish, which would refutate your argument about Celtic Identity.

During the times of Rome, Canaanites as an identity were vanished. And by the time of the Samaritan revolt before the Arab invasion many Jews lived in Judea.... Because there had to be Jews to revolt.

Now in this paragraph you mention the revolts that happened. First stop using the term "canaanite" because by this time it's a dead term and irrelevant.

It's absurd to think that migration happened during the 5th century because in the 6th century many Samaritan Jews revolted against Byzantine, a clear note that Judea was still predominantly Jewish.

But please stop talking about "Old Canaanites". No historian in their right mind would refer to Canaanites during the Middle Ages, it's a dead term, you're just making propganda by using a dead ethnicity to promote a dead cause.

If Jews were happy to live in Palestine and acceptance and blablabla  why isn't it that it wasn't until the 20th century that Jews would regain their status of majority in Israel?

The only way we can have some peace there is by removing an evil creation? AKA more endless wars?

1948? 1967? 1973? 1982? How many wars will arabs have to wage until they realise that the only way to do about palestine is to make a peace deal with Isreal?

You're just warmongering, no wonder the arab world is stuck behind Israel's progress.

And do not even mock me as an "insecure" person, because you of course defend a dead war the arabs cannot win.

Talk 17:32, August 8, 2018 (UTC)